Reality of 10% Reservation for Economically Weak: New Jumla? | Opinion by Dhruv Rathee

ਨੂੰ ਪ੍ਰਕਾਸ਼ਿਤ ਕੀਤਾ ਗਿਆ 9 ਜਨਵਰੀ 2019
Union cabinet on Monday approved 10% reservation in jobs and educational institutions for economically weak sections in general category. This will be given over and above the existing 50% reservation. In this video, I will tell you why I think this new scheme is nothing but a Jumla and a Lollipop to appease voters. The data suggests that more than 90% of general category people are eligible for being ‘Economically weak” and poor according to new criterion (based on my assumptions). So the question arises here, will the real poor people even benefit from this? What is the point of this new reservation? Ironically, people sill have to pay income tax despite being eligible under this category. Sources: www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/budget/only-76-lakh-indians-showed-income-of-over-rs-5-lakh-jaitley/article9514752.ecewww.thehindu.com/news/national/obc-creamy-layer-income-limit-raised-to-8-lakh-per-annum/article19677545.ecel
timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/almost-every-indian-now-covered-by-one-quota-or-another/articleshow/67429441.cms
Support my work: www.patreon.com/dhruvrathee
----------------------------------------------------
For more informative videos and discussion on important Indian and world issues-
Telegram channel to receive instant video updates: t.me/dhruvratheechannel
Support on Patreon: www.patreon.com/dhruvrathee Subscribe: pa-tv.com/username-dhruvrathee
Facebook: facebook.com/DhruvRatheePage
Twitter: twitter.com/dhruv_rathee
Instagram: instagram.com/dhruvrathee
More Interviews by Dhruv Rathee: pa-tv.com/username-playlist?list...
All episodes of The Dhruv Rathee Show:
Ep 9 Black Money: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-UdNe4Bv8ARY.html
Ep 8 RTI Activists: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-zE_tnXDXlaI.html
Ep 7 Ache Din in UP: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-dPvM2n2AFAw.html
Ep 6 Lairs Modi, Ivanka: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-jt14K39g7Tw.html
Ep 5 Padmavati: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-1M9XXdpuiaw.html
Ep 4 Rajasthan: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-y26_c2jNPUw.html
Ep 3 Jay Shah growth: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-FfTpWUPsdsc.html
Ep 2 Indian economy: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-1ZIFEASmno0.html
Ep 1 Currency Notes: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-sAH9YyR3O4c.html
More videos:
Rahul Gandhi vs Modi: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-Lem7KgAb9SY.html
PayTM reality: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-cseroHjs__E.html
Air Pollution: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-Yo_mO0L8uE4.html
BJP IT Cell part 2: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-BslKjxaP4Ik.html
Maun Modi: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-KOudMPiJFBI.html
Indian Education: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-ABmXRhizz4I.html
PNB Scam: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-5dL4AtHYd1w.html
Bitcoin: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-Kesk8WK1uWM.html
Aadhaar Card: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-S_bvQO6K5fY.html
Best State in India: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-XPwVq56l1rk.html
Petrol Prices reality: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-OSQXo3DpFAg.html
Budget 2018: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-Ncjcg97P1Tg.html
Save Our Forests: pa-tv.com/tv/%E0%A8%B5%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%A1%E0%A9%80%E0%A8%93-jHmXSpTVjZA.html
----------------------------------------------------

ਟਿੱਪਣੀਆਂ

  • Many people are questioning my assumption that SC/ST/OBC candidates don't compete with general candidates in open category seats. The reason for my assumption is simple. You must have seen often that even the reserved seats for SC, ST, OBC are lying vacant because there aren't enough candidates to fill them up. Here is a report which shows that OBCs just take up 12% of the jobs, far less than their reserved percentage. Same with SC/ST. Therefore, it is totally ok to assume that they were not really competing for the open category seats. Read: timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/20-years-after-Mandal-less-than-12-OBCs-in-central-govt-jobs/articleshow/50328073.cms

    • I disagree with your assumption that SC/ST/OBC seats remain vacant. This may be true in very few places. If you take example of engineering and Medical entrance exams or ssc cgl and ibps exams, you won't find any vacant reserved seats. So, after 50% reserved seats, remaining 50% seats are open to compete for all classes. I didn't expect from you to assume things because you seemed like a person who talks about facts. So, I request you to put facts in your video instead of giving assumptions. Caste based reservation was a political stunt. It has only enhanced the differences between different castes and is used to gain only political means. Caste based reservation must be abolished as well as caste based system. With right to equality, caste based system shouldn't exist. But society needs time to reform. It was possible until caste based reservation was not introduced. But it seems impossible now because governments(state and central) have trapped us. They will not let people forget that they are backward and their caste based politics will go on.

    • wtf CGL ME obc sari post le kr jate hai chek kr gen ki bhi kha jate hai

    • Genius man

  • Chup kr tohar bahinchodo

  • 50%NotForGeneralItisOpenForAll

  • compitition exam kabhi fight nhi kiya bhai tune

  • Household income dude, not individual ! Stop showing it for individuals !

  • Acha h kam se kam 10% to general aayega hi. I think this is good.

  • Problem kya h bhai

  • But the good thing can happen is this, now other castes people like Jaat, Patel, Martha revolution for OBC reservation will stop. They will not ask for reservation any more.

  • Logonko yeda banana band karo ......

  • Chall bhaii tum tou wo ho ...dusre kii thalii m gheee ghno lage.... Beta... Tum.. Lage raho "aap" bole tou keju ke sath... Fek news or paise lekar chall be jhuthaa

  • intelligent gen ki 10 % seats air kam ho gai we gen don't want it

  • आपका यह कार्य प्रशंसनीय है...धन्यवाद....

  • There is need for reservation for socially and educationally backward classes but it have to be amended frequently and the relaxation of such reservation should be amended too.

  • I agree with your point. Reservation for economically weak family is a bad move.

  • Ye to bahut galat assumptions betha diye sir apne.....Aur OBC SC St ki seats khali rahne wala point bhi apka valid nahi hai ...Govt exam ki prep kar rhe hai itna to pata hai....Aur 10% apne aise kaise man liya ki 50 % me se de diya ...Vo 50% gen category ka nahi balki unreserved category ka tha.....OBC SC St k sath dokha hua hai ...Vo 50% open seats nahi rhi...Ab 40 % hi rhi hai

  • Bhai apnaaa apna video k bich m ana wala add Ko dekha ek bar dekhna IT CELL WLA TU APKO BHI NHI CHODDTA

  • Chup Gaddafi

  • Tum yrrrr bht glt jhut bol rhe ho pgl ho kya tum

  • Jay from Sholay to Basanti- Ise Bak Bak karne ki aadat hai Feku saala

  • Jo 50% up general k lia reserved bol raheho usme baki bacha St ,sc ,obc v ate hai... Phele akhra thik se dekho phir video banao pure India me general categori k log 30%hai up bolraeho general 50%hai...

  • Modi is one of the Most disaster to the india

  • Sorry sir pr aapko is maamle kuch km knowlege hai pr is ka koi fayda nhi hai pr haa agar modi ji muje mil jaaye to unme 1000 joote markr puchoonga ki is ews reservation ka fayda kya hai agar aap main se kisi ko 1 bhi fayda pta ho to btaaye shayad main samaj nhi paa rha ar modi ji mile to 2 joote maare

  • Dhruv rathee always provide wrong wrong wrong wrong news. People's who are supporting him plz check the all facts which he provides u and also check that he is getting luv from pakistan.

  • Apko Rahul Gandhi kitna paisa khilata hai ????

  • paid by kejru bal

  • Unlike karne bale pakka 10% me se aate h

  • Tu khud is duniya ka sbse bada jumla h 😂😂😂😂😂

  • dhruv desh ki janta sam samajti hai.don't be biased.2.50.000 income personal income hain aur 800000 income family ka income hain

  • I like it...

  • Aaj general ko sirf 10% reservation Kya milane ki koshish Hui inhe dukh hua obc and Sc ke reservation ke bare me video bnao aur btao ki Jo iska labh pa chuke h wo reservation chhode

  • Teri kyu jal rhi h

  • You are very logical. Ye reservation sirf vote k lie h

  • You are right

  • ध्रुव जी। एक बात समझा दीजिए। एससी एसटी ओबीसी वाले अच्छा मार्क्स पा कर जनरल कैटेगरी में भी सेलेक्ट होते हैं। तो ये EWS केवल १०% पर नहीं बल्की पूरे ५०% पर फाइट करेंगे।

  • ध्रुव जी। एक बात समझा दीजिए। एससी एसटी ओबीसी वाले अच्छा मार्क्स पा कर जनरल कैटेगरी में भी सेलेक्ट होते हैं। तो ये EWS केवल १०% पर नहीं बल्की पूरे ५०% पर फाइट करेंगे।

  • जय हो धूर्त राठी की।।

  • Actually we need a leader. Not a politician,politician only know to play politics to Increase vote bank

  • Shame on you dhruv

  • Akdam right

  • The real fact is this whatever you share with us

  • Hum general walo ka sabhi marte aarahe hai lekin hum to protest karenge nahi,kyun ki humeh to do waqt roti ki zyada fiqar hai.mai general hote hua bhi caste walo support karta hu kyun ki woh log aapni haq ke liye raste par utar te hai aur aapni haq leker rehte hai. Baki sabhi political parties bhi to aapna faida chahenge hi, kounsa unhe des ko swadhin karwana hai ab jo fredoom fighters pehle sehi kar diye. Isse behtar to Britishers the jo aapne nahi the, lut mar karte the. General walo ko aur looto itna looto ke unhe wo do waqt ki roti bhi na mil paye tabh sayed nind se jagenge hum.

  • Bad me vacant seeto pr EWS walo ko job mil jayegi kyA

  • 6 lakhs in 2013 not in 2008...check it

  • Aapki tarah you tuber ban jayege App to.....

  • Y notified and not notified municipality ka mtlb??? Please explain

  • Tu apna kam karna madar.....

  • Mather jaat BJP CAG sab choor

  • Bilkul sahi kha

  • Right we need jobs 🙏

  • Ek Naya cast invention in 2019 with certificate. Jab India main ek bhi mandir, masjid,Gurudwara excatra aur south ke super hero alag hi hai jab tak in jungle book charecter Ko man na bandh nahi karte tab tak kuch nahi ho sakta. Britishers nahi jate ya Jo ki hum proudly khate hai hum Hindustaniyo ne unhe hara kar bhaga diya wo har kar gaye hamari intelligence se. Hum 99% products unhi ki use karte hai ya Bharosa karte hai. Kya hum Jeet gaye?

  • Jisko 33% reservation h use 12% job hi kese Lgta h koi phirki le rha h

  • To reservation htane ki bat kr

  • Kyu thak rha h

  • Ane dhru tuje itani jalan kyu hoti hai jumala nahi hai sach hai aur mene banava liya hai araban naksali

  • All Dislikers are Rich people's Who don't a poor persons get rich Shame on us

  • All Dislikers are SC 😂😂😂

  • Fuckoff

  • Well..........

  • bht log dhruv ko keval sunane m lge hain jbki bde hi logical way m dhruv ne isko smjhaya hai,ab reservation l name pr itni v kya khushi ki dimag kaam krna hi bnd krde

  • When yr relatives r congressman's then why u will be on the side of BJP. Overall yr income is from Cngs party

    • Rrb scam ssc scam

  • Result m reservation kyu dete h kyunki 90 number laane wale ko job nhi milti aur 60 number wale ko mil jati hai aisa kyun dhruv bhai?

  • sc/st seat fill na hone kiwajah unka hardwork na krna h

  • Very well👍 sir

  • Where u get all your figures from

  • Sahi baat hai

  • Right sir

  • Hello Dhruv, In Maharashtra, currently there is a on going case on Maratha reservation of 16% and it has led to issues for medical students seeking admission for neet pg as the percentage of open seats left is only 5% after that and also for the FYJC where the percentage of reservation reaches to 103% if such a bill becomes a law. The government has passed this just before elections and it has become very difficult for the students to get admission. How will a country progress if such law is passed to decide the future of the students. I request you to make a video on this topic and please let us know your views on this.

  • can you make a video on winning bjp in 2019? please solve the problem as soon as possible 😀😁😂🤔

  • Rather is our hero

  • make a video on RAKA's 'ji'.

  • Bhai I am requesting my fellow Indians to stop watching his channel. Agar tum logo ko abhi tak iska agenda aur biases samajh nhi aaye toh problem usme nhi tumme hai... Aise gadho ko 2-2 million views mil rahe and log bhi iske behkawe Mein aa rahe...pls STOP watching his channel.

  • Dhruv Rathee if you don't know the benefits of 10% reservation don't make video on this. Ohhh sorry I forgot you are working for a political party to tackle bjp everytime no Matter whether their decision is right or wrong.

    • What are benefits please explain??? Abe yeh reservation lollipop h lollipop

  • Supreme court ne rok nahi lgayi teri kya aukaat hi SUPREME court ke aage

  • I must say your analysis of different news and the way you cover each and every topic whether it be regarding rafale deal or reservation issue or how media is subdued all helps in increasing knowledge and force to think more about all this issues ,, I just had doubt the fact presented by times of India from which you also took help ,, what is source of this facts just wanted and please keep making such videos which enhances knowledge and make person to think more somewhere it's bring a great form of sensitivity in people's mind with regard to today's current scenario

  • Papa kejriwal ke gathbandhan ke liye bhi kuch bologi ki Nahi ?

  • Air college fee to kam hogi na job ka chodo

  • Basically GOVT. HAS PROVED INDIA IS A POOR COUNTRY. ..YOU CAN TAKE IT AGAINST HIS JUMLA (DESH KO JHUKNE NAHIN DUNGA)...☁🙏☁

  • Dhruv Rathee if you have guts have debate on handicap people reservation ..they get only 3%

    • Bhai, ye sirf modi k against wale topics uthata hai.. dusre nahi

  • Yeh gareebo ke khilaf hai

  • Aapne bahut accha bola isliye shukriya

  • U said ki ab general category vaale log sirf 10% kr liye compete krenge and baaki sc and st 50% already reserved ke liye than what about the left over 40% seats?

  • Are bewkoof jra dhyan se dekh ye January 2018 me nhi january 2019 me aaya h.jra data to sahi btaya kar

  • Are laudeke baal, specifically categorizing that OC and which are 20 percent of the total population

  • Abki bar to tune chutiyape ki parakashtha ko hi paar kr diya..

  • Dhruv Sir I want to know your opinion on kasmiri pandit Religion change....

  • To kaha g**d mraye jakar hm general wale 😏bc 68 marks (Gen.)wala fail or 60 (SC)wala clear.

  • May be there is no benefit of it... But bhai sahab... Reservation bhi 10 saal k liye hi tha. Jise 70 ho gye h.... Fortuner me ghumne wala "jaat, meena". Reservation le rhe h.. Or yha activa wale General category me.. Mehnat krke bhi berojgar bethe h.... Ye video bnane ji jagah. Koi gov. Exam de achha. Pdh or fir bhi jb teree job koi sc ya st wala le jayega to aake video bnana.. Dude reservation bnd mt kro.. Bus use cast ki jagah economically kr do.. Chahe sc ho. St. Ya general... But i know ye hoga nhi... Sabko politics krni h. Sarkar chlnai h.. Or general ki marni h... Kyoki hme पटरियों pr bethna nhi aata ⚔️

  • TOTALLY JUMLA

  • Gandve ye kyo nahi kahta survey hona chaiye samajik uthan ki bat karta hai kya ye ab bhi pichde hui hai ye ab tak pichde hai to 50 year tak pichde rahege survey karwa bewkuf bhimraw ne jo kar diya wo an bhi rahega kya ab halat dekh

  • Rahul gandhi par bhi koi video bana lijiye............ya phir aapko aisa lagta hai ki Rahul Gandhi ya Arvind Kejriwal koi galti karta hi nhi..................aap hamesha se BJP ko target karke videos banate hai.........ye samjh me ata h sabko ki aap v ek political party se belong karte ho....

  • Bhai ye 10% reservation ke liye BPL card chahiye isliye ye sirf kuch ko hi milega kyounki BPL card ki Limit 10000 annual hai jo 8 lakh wale ka banega hi nahi

  • Main point to. Likha hi nahi.. Age relaxation to hai hi nahi issmai

  • Bakloli kr rha h

  • Anti BJP bsdka

  • Janta ko iski awareness honi chaahey . But news channel wale to jhuti news he batate hai.ya pher Hindu Muslims ya modi modi

  • he dont know difference between unreserved category and general category

  • Nice job ....Sir keep it up👌👌👌

  • My family income is very less but I didn't get this quota. I don't know why there is number of criteria. The process of making EWS certificate is very complex. If 95 %indian are come into this quota why not this quota given to all general category people. So that people don't face problems while making EWS Certificate.

  • He is of course Feku Jumlebaazi Lunatic of the Nation

  • Sir lekin isme obc sc se competition nahi hoga